Instead of using loads of mayo, I lightened it up (a ton!) by using plain yogurt. No Mayo Pimiento Cheese Go to recipes By brandi-evans Vegetarian American Dips Clean Plate Club Instead of using loads of mayo, I lightened it up (a ton!) by using plain yogurt. Ready In: 10 mins Level: Easy Prep: 10 mins Cook: 0 mins Yields: 1 Cup Print Recipe Ingredients 1 1/2 c colby jack or cheddar cheese (shredded) 1/3 c Stonyfield Organic Low Fat Plain Yogurt 1 oz pimientos 1/2 t sugar 1/2 t white vinegar 1/2 t garlic powder 1/2 t onion powder 1/4 t black pepper directions Step 1Shred the cheese and place in a medium bowl.Step 2Add the yogurt, pimientos, sugar, vinegar, garlic powder, onion powder, and pepper. Mix everything together.Step 3Refrigerate until you're ready to serve.Step 4Spread onto bread for a sandwich, dollop it on crackers, or plop it on a burger. It's also good on a spoon.